TedW:His website, and especially his weekly column "Clusterfuck Nation", is also quite good, if depressing.If you would rather read Kunstler than watch his TED talk, this old article from The Atlantic is good.
Random? They're named after what used to be there. Oak Grove? Chopped them down. Vista Way? Can't see a thing. Sweet Spring? Filled with runoff from the lawns.There's often a marketing angle, too. Around where I grew up, the town was named with the formula [NATURE_THING_1 + NATURE_THING_2], even though it was built on top of farmland. The neighborhoods/gated communities followed the same formula, or else they were named after ivy league colleges or famous 19th century poets. Everything about the place, right down to the name of the local mall, was designed to project a faux-New England charm, as if to say, "Hey, future parents! If your kids grew up on Baudelaire Court, wouldn't they be destined for great things? Wouldn't you be so totally proud of yourself for doing everything in your power to make sure your genetic offspring quickly and permanently rise to the upper ranks of society, where they will discuss French poetry and the stock market every evening while sipping brandy?" I've always felt this blatant marketing to a certain type of real-estate consumer demographic was central to suburbia's character. The only remnants of what was there before were streets named after the family that owned a large estate in the area two hundred years ago.
> "They're named after what used to be there. Oak Grove? Chopped them down. Vista Way? Can't see a thing. Sweet Spring? Filled with runoff from the lawns."I completely agree with your comment; but as an interesting aside from my academic training as a geographer:
desjardins:I think this has been mentioned before on mefi, but the Citadel planned community - where gun ownership is mandatory - is the worst idea I've ever heard of in urban planning. Seriously? You're going to put the utilities right next to the amphitheater?
boo_radley:There's a ARMS FACTORY and gun reflecting pool, but no farmland? Honestly, this looks like a Dungeons and Dragons supplement more than anything else.
The Whelk:I disagree. That fortification design is so bad I think it's clear they never played D&D.I love, love, love the citadel link BTW, it goes into SUCH DETAIL about things that do not matter! It's like the world's worst D&D camapign, although I'm honestly surprised every house wasn't it's own mini fortress with tiny suburbian castle towers and parapets.
« Older 15 megaton kittens... | In 1907, Ida Wood checked into... Newer »
This thread has been archived and is closed to new comments
I disagree with some of the way he makes his points and some of his conclusions, but it's a good overview of the differences between architecture and whatever the hell suburbia is.
posted by tripping daisy at 7:25 AM on January 25 [2 favorites]