Join 3,557 readers in helping fund MetaFilter (Hide)

How America can win the Intelligence War
June 16, 2004 2:35 PM   Subscribe

The problem actually is quite simple. To advocate jihad today is the hallmark of the radical Islamist, and it is there that the West must draw a line in the sand. But to repudiate jihad in turn implies radical revision of the religion's mainstream, and that is the hallmark of the radical reformer. Like other religions, Islam has reached a point in world history - or rather world history has caught up with Islam - such that it must undergo a fundamental change. By way of comparison, the Catholic Church accepts separation of church and state as well as religious tolerance, but it did so only after the likes of Count Camillo Benso Cavour in Italy stripped the papacy of temporal rule over anything but the square mile of the Vatican City. Western leaders must not attack Islam; to take sides against any religion runs counter to the traditions of religious tolerance upon which the United States was founded. But they must denounce the use of force to propagate religion, and make it clear that they will match force with force. The enemy is not "terrorism", but any form of violence, including conventional warfare, in the service of religious expansionism.
posted by David Dark (0 comments total)

This post was deleted for the following reason: single op-ed link to a war story? no thanks.



 

« Older The Textbooks of Military Medicine....  |   Virtual Replay - Shockwave re... Newer »


This thread has been archived and is closed to new comments