A resolution simply proposing an investigation, even though impeachment may be a possible consequence, is not privileged. But where a resolution of investigation positively proposes impeachment or suggests that end, it has been admitted as of privilege.-Jefferson's Manual (PDF link)
In the House there are various methods of setting an impeachment in motion: by charges made on the floor on the responsibility of a Member or Delegate; by charges preferred by a memorial, which is usually referred to a committee for examination; by a resolution dropped in the hopper by a Member and referred to a committee; by a message from the President; by charges transmitted from the legislature of a State (III, 2469) or territory or from a grand jury; or from facts developed and reported by an investigating committee of the House. [edited for clarity]For the proposition that a legislature may transmit charges to the House, Jefferson cites Hinds' Precedents of the United States Senate, Volume III, Section 2469. Hinds, in turn, reports as follows:
The impeachment and trial of Charles Swayne, judge of the Northern District of Florida.In other words, as opposed to the claims of the article, there is no definite rule which requires the House to proceed with an impeachment when a state so requests. Instead, there is a precedent for the House to potentially initiate impeachment proceedings when so moved by a Representative who relies on a resolution passed by a state legislature. In other words, there is no formal mechanism by which the Illinois legislature can guarantee that the House will even notice its resolution.
A Member, rising in his place, impeached Judge Swayne both on his own responsibility and on the strength of a legislative memorial. ... On December 10, 1903, Mr. William B. Lamar, of Florida, claiming the floor for a question of privilege, said:Mr. Speaker, I believe that the impeachment of a civil officer by this House is a question of privilege. I have made a joint resolution adopted by the legislature of the State of Florida a part of the resolution which I desire to submit to this House for its adoption. In pursuance of this joint resolution of the legislature of the State which I have the honor in part to represent, I impeach Charles Swayne, judge of the northern district of the State of Florida, of high crimes and misdemeanors; and the resolution which I have prepared in accordance with former proceedings of this House in like cases....
The longer Bush is president, the more Democrats at the national and local level have to gain. So don't impeach the guy.

« Older I can't think for you. You'll have to decide. Whet... | A few songs about comic strips... Newer »
This thread has been archived and is closed to new comments
posted by Mayor Curley at 12:42 PM on April 25, 2006