I've heard stories about EMTs being cynical smartasses.Without being deliberately confrontational, how many EMTs and/or paramedics do you personally know? Popular culture, for some reason, seems to demand this particular pigeonhole be occupied by EMTs and paramedics, and it is wildly out of step with reality. There is a small minority of EMTs that are vocally burnt-out and patient-hostile, and, on my own authority, I will happily say that I'm certain 99% of their hostility comes from the working conditions under which they're forced to operate rather than their patients.
Doctors dehumanize their patients all the time, referring to them in an alphabet soup of TLAs and obscure latin terminology that distances them from the actual human being they're treating.No, some doctors do. Doctors, as a general profession, do not. You are extending your "I've met a few arrogant doctors, physician's assistants, and med students," to an entire profession, with no justification whatsoever and in the face of reality as reported by those of us who actually work in healthcare.
Patient (in agonizing pain): "I came in last year and it was exactly like this, and they gave me morphine and phenergan and told me it was X"And so forth, and so on.
Doctor: "Okay." Goes on doing what they're doing.
The doctor is dehumanizing the patient, and doesn't care what happens to them. They're probably not even listening.There's also
The doctor's burnt out, and they just don't care any more, the patient is just an annoyance to them.What I almost never hear said, except by people in frontline medicine, is
The doctor is processing what the patient is telling them, but trying to maintain objectivity while they complete their examination so that they do not commit the potentially fatal error of "seeking to find".There are hundreds of disorders that mimic each other with uncanny brilliance. In some cases, a potentially fatal disorder mimics a benign one, and the choice of treatment is critical.
Shocking statistical evidence is cited by Gary Null PhD, Caroly Dean MD ND, Martin Feldman MD, Debora Rasio MD and Dorothy Smith PhD in their recent paper Death by Medicine - October 2003, released by the Nutrition Institute of America.Let me count the problems with this "citation":
OK, scrup, no biggie. Just making a point. I'm sure we can "Bury the hatchet."What I want is for you to actually back up your assertions in some way involving actual, serious science. "The Johns Hopkins study"? Which study, from which authors, from what journal? Using what methodology? Provide a citation.
If you want more conservative numbers, look up the Johns Hopkins study that places Iatrogenic death as the #3 leading cause of death in the US. I won't bother linking to it, because its not important anyway.
« Older I'm Coming Home... | It's on the Internet, so it mu... Newer »
This thread has been archived and is closed to new comments
posted by blucevalo at 9:36 AM on August 23, 2006