Critics who saw the film last autumn at the Venice and Toronto festivals walked in expecting the disaster they'd read about from Cannes. Here is Bill Chambers of Film Freak Central, writing from Toronto: "Ebert catalogued his mainstream biases (unbroken takes: bad; non-classical structure: bad; name actresses being aggressively sexual: bad) ... and then had a bigger delusion of grandeur than 'The Brown Bunny's' Gallo-centric credit assignations: 'I will one day be thin but Vincent Gallo will always be the director of 'The Brown Bunny.' "I've actually never seen a Gallo film (though people around this town have a bizarre fascination with Buffalo 66), but I can definitely hear where Ebert's coming from on this one -- and not only with film. I've workshpped a lot of stories that desperately needed to have stuff cut out of them that the authors thought was crusial to understanding the story. At least it seems that Gallo was able to get past the insult and do what was necessary.
Faithful readers will know that I admire long takes, especially by Ozu, that I hunger for non-classical structure, and that I have absolutely nothing against sex in the cinema. In quoting my line about one day being thin, Chambers might in fairness have explained that I was responding to Gallo calling me a "fat pig" -- and, for that matter, since I made that statement I have lost 86 pounds and Gallo is indeed still the director of "The Brown Bunny."
But he is not the director of the same "Brown Bunny" I saw at Cannes, and the film now plays so differently that I suggest the original Cannes cut be included as part of the eventual DVD, so that viewers can see for themselves how 26 minutes of aggressively pointless and empty footage can sink a potentially successful film. ...
Imagine, little old me, the great Vincent Gallo, getting to interview him, oh my God, the great Vincent Gallo.withouth your self-parodydar* going off, then...well, I guess you're just a far more suspicious reader of celebrity culture than I am.
« Older Border Fence Firm Snared for Hiring Illegal Worker... | The most inspirational film ev... Newer »
This thread has been archived and is closed to new comments
posted by fire&wings at 10:29 AM on December 15, 2006