Comments on: The things they returned

The things they returned

LenaO — Thu, 25 Jun 2009 11:18:25 -0800

In 1970, while burning captured enemy documents with no military intelligence value, Fred Whitehurst came across a tiny diary. Advised not to burn it by his translator, he kept it and took it with him to America when his tour was over. Thirty five years later, the diary came back home.

That diary belonged to Dang Thuy Tram (she went by her middle name Thuy), a young doctor from the North. Freshly out from medical school, she followed the NVA down South and set up a clinic in Quang Ngai province, one of the fiercest battle ground in Vietnam (this is where My Lai happened). Young, idealistic and passionate, she wrote about her patients, her desires to join the Communist party, her childhood love, and most of all about her longing for family and friends: More links: Scan of the diary: (In Vietnamese) Last night I dream of Peace Translated by Andrew X.Pham, author of Catfish and Mandala Audio interview with the Whitehurst brothers and excerpts from the diary Women in war: Radio interview with Fred Whitehurst How the two families bonded Previously on things returned by old enemies.

By: chunking express

chunking express — Thu, 25 Jun 2009 11:23:58 -0800

This is good.

By: LenaO

LenaO — Thu, 25 Jun 2009 11:24:29 -0800

A few more articles with excerpts to the diary if anybody's interested here here and here Also I really do believe it is entirely possible that the man who returned the photo knew this story and was encouraged by how the Whitehurst brothers were embraced by the Dang family.

By: Malice

Malice — Thu, 25 Jun 2009 11:39:28 -0800

Some things I find interesting. 1.) Every time the man (who found the diary) is going to say something nice about the Vietnamese, as a precursor he reiterates how much he is not a pacifist and how much he agrees with war (even when he states clearly that there must be a better way.) 2.) The diary came to him in two parts? And he only said this after someone pointed out that he said he got it in 69 and the last entry is from 1970? 3.) The mother was presented with a copy instead of the original? Cold. 4.) They say 'the diary' but wouldn't it be TWO diaries, if he found it in two parts? I'm a little lost there.

By: HabeasCorpus

HabeasCorpus — Thu, 25 Jun 2009 11:55:30 -0800

"Don't burn this one...it has fire in it already." wow.

By: zia

zia — Sat, 27 Jun 2009 06:07:53 -0800

The original are at the Vietnamese archives in Lubbock Texas; the mother and daughters were flown there and were able to look at them there. The diaries have been published and are a sensation in Vietnam. "I want so much a mother's hand to care for me. Love me and give me strength to travel the hard sections of the road ahead." As the mother of a seven month old daughter this one touched me deeply.