Clay Shirky smacks syllogism around. Nice criticism of the
semantic web and the present (and increasing) hype of the
"semantic web revolution". The most damning part of the essay is the part about languages and categories being deeply intertwined with worldview and with culture—if there's no good definition for the word
"bachelor" (
see), how can there be an encoding of
"friend",
"lover" (see article for the classic AI example of
"John loves Mary") or anything else that isn't zipcode?
posted by zpousman
on Nov 8, 2003 -
62 comments
Another year, another Chat. This year's
Loebner Prize competition will be held next week in Atlanta, GA
(at SciTrek and GSU). The yearly contest is a modified
"Turing test" (seminal paper here) where people try to guess whether they're chatting with computers or with people.
There are some resources for
rolling your own
AI bot, but before you begin, think about these two sentences and you'll see what a serious problem natural language is: "We gave the monkeys the bananas because they were
hungry" and "We gave the monkeys the bananas because they were
ripe"
(nod to this guy for the example). You have to know a lot about the world and the things in it to disambiguate the
"they" in those sentences.
posted by zpousman
on Sep 20, 2002 -
15 comments
