Join 3,363 readers in helping fund MetaFilter (Hide)

2 posts tagged with scotus by three blind mice.
Displaying 1 through 2 of 2.

Related tags:
+ (55)
+ (47)
+ (14)
+ (14)
+ (12)
+ (11)
+ (10)
+ (9)
+ (9)
+ (9)
+ (9)
+ (8)
+ (8)
+ (6)
+ (6)
+ (6)
+ (6)
+ (6)
+ (6)
+ (6)
+ (5)
+ (5)
+ (5)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)
+ (4)


Users that often use this tag:
roomthreeseventeen (12)
monju_bosatsu (12)
XQUZYPHYR (6)
homunculus (3)
zarq (3)
insectosaurus (3)
VikingSword (2)
reductiondesign (2)
Rhaomi (2)
three blind mice (2)
falconred (2)
Navelgazer (2)
modernnomad (2)
anotherpanacea (2)
jeffburdges (2)
Dreama (2)
baylink (2)

Crime doesn't pay.

Tighter restrictions on damage awards. The two questions presented to the U.S. Supreme Court centered on whether or not the highly reprehensible conduct of a defendant is analogous to a crime and can "override" the constitutional requirement that punitive damages be reasonably related to the plaintiffs harm. The answer is no. (21 page pdf) Held: 1. A punitive damages award based in part on a jury’s desire to punish a defendant for harming nonparties amounts to a taking of property from the defendant without due process. The majority: Roberts, Alito, Kennedy, Souter, and Breyer. Dissenting: Ginsburg, Scalia, Stevens, and Thomas.
posted by three blind mice on Feb 20, 2007 - 37 comments

... a page of history is worth a volume of logic.

Injunctions in patent cases not automatic. The U.S. Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision (16 page pdf) on Monday in the dispute between eBay and MercExchange. The Court ruled in favor of eBay finding that the lower Appeals Court erred as a matter of law in creating a general rule that “courts will issue permanent injunctions against patent infringement absent exceptional circumstances.” In the concurring opinion written by Chief Justice Roberts, joined by Scalia and Ginsberg, Roberts citing Court precedent noted that: “[d]iscretion is not whim, and limiting discretion according to legal standards helps promote the basic principle of justice that like cases should be decided alike.”
posted by three blind mice on May 17, 2006 - 25 comments

Page: 1