SubscribeFor the beginning of the Afghan war, there is no source of comparable scope, insight and accuracy. Kakar's political sympathies are quite clear --- he is a modernizing, Muslim, democratic nationalist --- but I can find no point at which they have distorted his narrative or conclusions (and I am a cosmopolite atheist, and looked). His writing --- in perfectly grammatical if unpolished English --- is almost always level and simply descriptive; those who want impassioned rhetoric will have to look elsewhere. Yet the words Tacitus sets at the beginning of his Histories ---Cosma turns out to be a child of the Afghan diaspora. languagehat and Zurishaddai may have picked up on that but I sure had no clue...
I am entering on the history of a period rich in disasters, frightful in its wars, torn by civil strife, and even in peace full of horrors
--- might serve as Kakar's epigraph. Tyranny; invasion; rebellion; cruelty; slaughter; the exodus of a people; the destruction of a country by those who professed to be its saviors (``they make a desert and call it peace''): all this recounted in a level academic voice produces an effect of quiet, mounting horror. The horror has not ended yet; and I fear it will not end for a long time to come.
« Older So there's this elk carcass on my front yard and t... | Dolphin minesweeper returns fr... Newer »
This thread has been archived and is closed to new comments
posted by MiguelCardoso at 6:57 PM on April 3, 2003